8 min read

Automated vs Manual Reference Checks: What’s Best for Your Business?

When hiring new employees, choosing between manual and automated reference checks is crucial, as each method offers unique benefits like personal insights or speed and efficiency. Explore this guide to discover which approach suits your business best and learn tips to make your reference checks more effective.

When it comes to hiring new employees, one of the most important steps is checking references. This step is like checking the weather before you head out; you want to be prepared for what lies ahead. But the question arises: should you opt for automated reference checks or stick with the traditional manual reference checks? Each method has its perks, and in this guide, we will walk you through the options to find out what fits your business best.

‍

What Are Reference Checks?

Reference checks are inquiries made to verify a candidate’s employment history and qualifications. They help you understand the candidate's past performance and character. Think of it as getting the inside scoop from someone who has been there, done that. You want to hear how they have shined in previous roles or if they have left a trail of chaos behind.

‍

The Old School Approach: Manual Reference Checks

Manual reference checks have been the go-to method for many years. This traditional approach involves contacting the references provided by the candidate and asking them questions about their work experience, skills, and character.

Pros of Manual Reference Checks

Personal Touch: When you speak directly with someone, it feels more personal. You can gauge their tone and enthusiasm as they speak about the candidate.
Flexibility: You can adapt your questions based on the reference’s responses, which can lead to more in-depth conversations.
Building Rapport: Establishing a connection with references can create goodwill, which may come in handy for your business in the future.

Cons of Manual Reference Checks

Time-Consuming: Reaching out to references can take a lot of time, especially if you are juggling multiple candidates.
Availability Issues: Sometimes, references may be busy or hard to reach, which can slow down your hiring process.
Potential Bias: References are often handpicked by candidates, which can lead to biased feedback. It is like asking a friend to recommend a movie; they may only suggest their favorites, not necessarily the best options.

‍

The New Wave: Automated Reference Checks

With technology evolving at lightning speed, many businesses are turning to automated reference checks. This method utilizes software or online platforms to gather feedback from references quickly and efficiently.

Pros of Automated Reference Checks

Speed: Automated systems can gather references in a fraction of the time it takes to do it manually. You can receive feedback while you are sipping your morning coffee.
Standardized Questions: Automated checks often use a consistent set of questions, which can provide uniformity in the feedback received. This standardization can help in making comparisons between candidates.
Less Bias: With AI reference checks, the candidate's selected references may not be the only ones providing feedback. Some systems allow for broader input, giving a more well-rounded view of the candidate.

Cons of Automated Reference Checks

Lack of Personal Touch: While automation is quick, it may miss the nuance and personality that a human conversation can provide.
Technical Glitches: Like any technology, automated systems can experience glitches or errors, leading to potential delays or inaccuracies.
Limited Flexibility: Automated checks are typically less adaptable. Once you start, you cannot easily change the questions based on the reference's responses.

Choosing What is Best for Your Business

So, how do you decide which method to use? It often comes down to your specific needs and circumstances. Here are some factors to consider:

1. The Size of Your Business

If you run a small business and are hiring one or two employees, a manual reference check might be sufficient. You can invest the time to build a relationship with references. However, if you are a larger company hiring in bulk, automated reference checks might save you a significant amount of time.

2. The Nature of the Position

For positions requiring a lot of trust and responsibility, such as management roles, a manual reference check might allow for deeper insights. You want to ensure that the person you hire can be trusted, and sometimes that requires a good old-fashioned chat. On the other hand, for entry-level positions, an automated reference check can quickly get you the information you need without getting too bogged down.

3. Available Resources

If you have a dedicated HR team, they may prefer manual checks for the personal touch. However, if your resources are limited, utilizing automation tools for reference checks can help your team focus on more strategic tasks.

‍

Making the Most of Your Choice

No matter which method you choose, there are a few tips to keep in mind to maximize your reference check process:

Be Clear About What You Want to Know

Before you start checking references, take a moment to clarify what information you need. Whether you are doing it manually or automatically, knowing your objectives will help you ask the right questions.

Create a Standard Process

If you choose to go the manual route, consider developing a standard list of questions. This helps to keep your checks consistent and ensures you gather similar information from each reference.

Consider Combining Methods

Why not have the best of both worlds? Start with an automated reference check to gather quick insights and then follow up with a few key references manually for more in-depth discussions. This hybrid approach can save time while still offering personal touchpoints.

‍

Conclusion

In the end, the choice between automated and manual reference checks boils down to what fits your business best. Both methods have their strengths and weaknesses, and it is important to consider your specific situation. Automated reference checks can provide speed and efficiency, while manual checks offer depth and personal connection.

By weighing the pros and cons of each method, you will be well-equipped to make the right decision for your hiring process. Remember, finding the right employee is like finding a needle in a haystack, and thorough reference checks can make all the difference in ensuring you select the perfect fit for your team.

So, whether you opt for automation or stick to the classic approach, take your time, be thoughtful, and remember: the right reference check can lead to the right hire, which ultimately benefits your entire business. Happy hiring!

‍