8 min read

How to Avoid Discrimination in Online Reference Checks

Ensuring fairness and avoiding discrimination in online reference checks is crucial for both compliance and building a respectful hiring process. To learn practical tips on conducting bias-free reference checks and staying aligned with legal guidelines, read the full article.

Online reference checks are a great way to dig deeper into a candidate’s background. But here is the thing—without the right approach, you could unintentionally cross a line and end up discriminating. As a business owner, you need to keep your hiring fair, square, and in line with legal standards.

Let us break down how you can avoid discrimination in your online reference checks, ensure fairness, and stay on the right side of compliance guidelines like the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) regulations.

‍

Why Avoiding Discrimination in Hiring Matters

Discrimination in hiring does not just harm the candidates. It can also come back to bite your business. A single case of perceived unfair treatment can damage your reputation and cost you dearly in lawsuits or lost trust.

When conducting online reference checks, unconscious biases often sneak in. Maybe a glowing review makes you lean toward one candidate or a cultural difference in communication style unintentionally sets you against another. This is why it is critical to approach every candidate evaluation with a fair mindset.

‍

Understanding Bias in Hiring

What is bias? It is when personal preferences or stereotypes influence your decisions. While it is natural for humans to have biases, in hiring, they can lead to serious discrimination issues.

Types of Bias You Might Encounter

Affinity Bias: Favoring someone because they remind you of yourself or share your background.
Confirmation Bias: Interpreting information in a way that supports pre-existing opinions.
Stereotyping: Making assumptions based on a candidate’s race, gender, age, or other factors.

Even well-meaning employers can fall prey to these biases. Recognizing them is the first step to addressing the problem.

‍

Follow EEOC Compliance Guidelines

The EEOC exists to ensure that workplaces remain free of discrimination. To comply with these guidelines during online reference checks:

Ask Consistent Questions: Make sure every candidate is asked the same set of questions. This keeps things fair and avoids singling anyone out based on personal traits.
Avoid Probing Personal Details: Never ask about a candidate’s marital status, religion, or age. These details are not relevant to their job performance.
Document Everything: Keep detailed records of all reference check conversations and decisions. If questioned, you need to show that your process was unbiased.

‍

Conduct Reference Checks Fairly and Transparently

The key to avoiding discrimination is a transparent and fair approach. When contacting references, treat each candidate equally. Here are some golden rules:

Stick to Job-Related Questions: Focus only on skills, achievements, and work ethics. Avoid asking personal or inappropriate questions.
Use Structured Templates: Prepare a set of standardized questions for every reference check. This levels the playing field.
Evaluate Facts, Not Opinions: References might offer personal impressions, but you should base your decisions on verifiable information.

‍

Tips to Minimize Unconscious Bias

Unconscious bias can creep into your hiring process without you even realizing it. Here are some practical ways to keep it in check:

Train Your Team: Invest in training sessions to help your hiring team recognize and address their biases.
Blind Reference Checks: Avoid seeing identifying information, like names or gender, until after evaluating the reference feedback.
Use Technology Carefully: If you use software tools to assist with hiring, ensure they are programmed to avoid biased recommendations.

‍

Be Aware of Legal Risks

Did you know that discrimination during hiring can lead to lawsuits under anti-discrimination laws? Reference checks are no exception. Staying informed about potential legal pitfalls is essential.

Common Legal Issues to Watch Out For

Defamation Claims: A bad reference that turns out to be untrue can lead to lawsuits.
Negligence in Hiring: Skipping reference checks altogether could result in hiring someone unfit for the role, exposing your company to liability.

‍

Adopt a Fair and Empathetic Tone

When reaching out to references, keep your tone professional but empathetic. Remember, references are people too, and how you engage with them reflects on your business.

Examples of Fair Questions to Ask References

"How would you describe the candidate’s approach to problem-solving?"
"Can you share an example of how they contributed to team projects?"

Steer clear of personal or intrusive questions like:

"Did they have any personal issues at work?"
"Are they planning to have kids soon?"

‍

Educate Yourself and Your Team on Anti-Discrimination Laws

Knowledge is power. Keeping up-to-date with anti-discrimination laws can help you and your team avoid costly mistakes. Resources from the EEOC are a great starting point.

Key Takeaways for Your Team

Always focus on job-related criteria.
Be consistent in your questioning and evaluations.
Keep detailed records to back up your decisions.

‍

Regularly Review Your Hiring Practices

Even if you think your process is airtight, it is a good idea to review your hiring practices periodically. Invite external experts to audit your process, or use feedback from candidates to identify potential blind spots.

‍

Create an Inclusive Hiring Policy

To take things a step further, develop an inclusive hiring policy. This policy should clearly outline how discrimination will be avoided at every stage of recruitment, including reference checks.

‍

Final Thoughts on Avoiding Discrimination

Avoiding discrimination in online reference checks is not just about following laws—it is about building a fair and respectful hiring process. Treat every candidate equally, keep your process consistent, and stay informed about the latest anti-discrimination guidelines.

‍