8 min read

The Art of Interviewing References: Questions You Must Ask

Interviewing references is a crucial yet often overlooked step in the hiring process, offering insights into a candidate's work ethic, strengths, and cultural fit that aren't visible on a resume. Discover essential questions and practical tips to make these conversations meaningful—read on to master this key hiring skill!

When it comes to hiring the right people for your business, you probably spend a lot of time thinking about resumes, skills, and interviews. However, one crucial step often gets overlooked: interviewing references. This process can provide valuable insights into a candidate’s past performance, work ethic, and potential fit for your team. So, how do you get the most out of these conversations? Let us guide you through the essential questions you must ask when interviewing references.

Why Interviewing References Matters

You might wonder, “Why should I even bother with reference interviews?” Well, think of it this way: when you buy a car, you do not just look at the exterior and the flashy interior. You want to know how it runs, how it performs, and if it is worth your hard-earned cash. Interviewing references gives you a clearer picture of a candidate’s “engine” — their work habits, strengths, and weaknesses. It can be the difference between hiring a rock star and someone who merely looks good on paper.

Preparing for the Reference Interview

Before you pick up the phone or schedule a call, you need to prepare. Here are some tips to help you get ready for the reference interview:

Review the Candidate’s Application: Familiarize yourself with the candidate's background and the specific role they are applying for. This way, you can tailor your questions accordingly.
Craft Open-Ended Questions: Prepare questions that invite detailed responses. Instead of asking yes or no questions, ask for examples and stories that illustrate the candidate's skills and experiences.
Schedule a Convenient Time: When reaching out to references, ask for a time that works for them. Respect their schedule and give them a heads-up about the topics you want to discuss.
Set the Right Tone: Begin the conversation by introducing yourself and explaining the purpose of your call. This helps to establish trust and sets the stage for an open dialogue.

Questions You Must Ask

Now that you are ready, here are some questions to consider during your reference interview. These queries will help you gain deeper insights into the candidate’s work history and character.

1. What was your working relationship with the candidate?

This question helps you understand the context of their feedback. Did they work closely together, or were they more like passing acquaintances? A direct supervisor may offer different insights compared to a colleague or a client.

2. Can you describe the candidate’s strengths?

Ask for specific examples of the candidate’s strengths in action. Did they handle a challenging project with finesse? Were they able to rally the team when the pressure was on? Look for qualities that align with the position they are applying for.

3. What areas do you think the candidate could improve on?

No one is perfect. This question opens the door for the reference to share constructive feedback. If the reference provides insights on areas for growth, take note of them. You may want to discuss these points with the candidate during the next stage of the hiring process.

4. How did the candidate handle feedback or criticism?

It is essential to know how a potential hire reacts to feedback. Do they take it in stride, or do they struggle with it? A person who can accept constructive criticism is more likely to grow and adapt within your organization.

5. How did the candidate work in a team setting?

Collaboration is key in many workplaces. You want to know if the candidate is a team player or if they prefer to work alone. Understanding their interpersonal skills will help you determine if they will fit well within your company culture.

6. Would you rehire this candidate? Why or why not?

This question is often telling. If a reference would gladly bring someone back, that speaks volumes about their past performance. Conversely, if they hesitate or provide a long-winded explanation, it may raise a red flag.

7. Can you share an example of a challenge the candidate faced and how they overcame it?

Challenges are inevitable in any job. This question allows the reference to provide a narrative that showcases the candidate’s problem-solving skills, resilience, and creativity. Listen for stories that illustrate how they tackle obstacles.

8. How did the candidate contribute to the company’s culture?

Company culture is essential for team dynamics. Understanding how a candidate interacts with others can help you assess whether they will thrive in your work environment. A positive cultural fit often leads to better teamwork and job satisfaction.

Conducting Phone Checks: A Best Practice

When it comes to phone checks, they can be a game-changer in the reference interviewing process. While emails can be efficient, nothing beats a good ol' phone call for building rapport and extracting meaningful insights. Here are a few reasons to pick up the phone:

Real-Time Interaction: You can ask follow-up questions based on the reference’s responses. This flexibility allows for a more natural conversation.
Tone and Emotion: Hearing someone’s voice can convey feelings that written words may not capture. Pay attention to tone, hesitation, and enthusiasm. These cues can provide additional context.
Establishing Trust: A phone call creates a personal connection. References may feel more comfortable sharing candid feedback when speaking directly with you.

Tips for a Successful Reference Interview

Here are a few tips to keep in mind during the reference interview:

Listen Actively: Pay close attention to what the reference is saying. Nodding and using affirmations like "I see" or "That makes sense" can encourage them to share more.
Take Notes: Jot down key points during the conversation. These notes will help you remember what each reference said when you are comparing candidates later on.
Be Respectful: Respect the reference’s time and opinions. If they seem hesitant to answer a question, do not push too hard. Instead, move on to the next topic.
Follow Up: After the interview, thank the reference for their time. If you learned something valuable, share that with them. A simple thank you can go a long way in building rapport.

Wrapping Up Your Reference Interviewing

After conducting your reference interviews, take time to evaluate the feedback you have received. Look for patterns in what multiple references say about the candidate. Consistent positive remarks can indicate a strong fit, while conflicting information may require further consideration.

In conclusion, interviewing references is an essential step in the hiring process. The questions you ask can help reveal valuable insights that might not be evident in a resume or interview. By approaching these conversations thoughtfully and respectfully, you can make more informed decisions that benefit your business.

When it comes to assembling your team, every little detail counts. By mastering the art of interviewing references, you are taking a significant step toward hiring the right people who will contribute positively to your business’s success. So, go ahead and make those calls—you may just discover your next star employee!

‍