8 min read

Understanding Employment Reference Checks: A Complete Guide

Employment reference checks are a crucial step in the hiring process that go beyond resumes and interviews, allowing employers to verify a candidate's work history, skills, and character by speaking with previous employers or colleagues. This comprehensive guide offers invaluable insights into conducting effective reference checks, legal considerations, and strategies for making informed hiring decisions that can ultimately save businesses time, money, and potential future headaches.

When hiring a new employee, there is more than just looking at a resume and nailing the interview. Employment reference checks are a key step in ensuring that the person you hire is who they say they are. Think of it as a background check, but instead of looking at someone's criminal record, you are verifying their work history, skills, and character. In this guide, we will walk through the ins and outs of employment reference checks, how they work, and why they matter for your business.

What Are Employment Reference Checks?

Employment reference checks are like a second opinion when hiring someone. You do not just want to take a candidate’s word for it—you want to hear it from someone who has worked with them before. These checks usually involve calling previous employers or colleagues to ask questions about the candidate’s job performance, reliability, and whether they are a good fit for the role.

It is like asking your neighbor if they know a good plumber before hiring one. You want to make sure you are bringing the right person into your business.

Why Are They Important for Your Business?

Imagine hiring someone based solely on their resume, only to find out that their skills were exaggerated, or worse, they do not have the experience they claimed. This can lead to all kinds of headaches—from poor job performance to high turnover rates.

Employment reference checks help you avoid that by verifying key details about the candidate. It is like doing your homework before making a big decision. This step can save you time, money, and frustration in the long run. It is better to know upfront if a candidate is not the right fit rather than finding out months later.

How Does the Process Work?

The process of checking references is not as complicated as it might seem. It typically goes like this:

Get Permission: Always ask the candidate for permission before contacting their references. This is not just a legal formality; it is a courtesy.
Reach Out to References: You will usually contact previous employers, supervisors, or colleagues. If the candidate provided personal references, make sure to ask them how they know the candidate and how long they have worked together.
Ask the Right Questions: This is the most important part. You want to ask questions that give you a real sense of the candidate’s abilities. Some common questions include:
- Can you confirm the candidate’s job title and responsibilities?
- How did they handle challenges at work?
- Would you rehire them?
- How well did they work with the team?

Employment Reference Checks vs. Employment Verification

You might be wondering, “Is an employment reference check the same thing as employment verification?” The short answer is no.

Employment reference checks are about getting a qualitative assessment of the candidate’s past job performance and character. It involves asking detailed questions to people who have worked with the candidate.
Employment verification, on the other hand, is a more straightforward process. This involves confirming that the candidate did, in fact, work at the places they listed on their resume, along with verifying job titles and dates of employment.

While both are important, employment reference checks give you a deeper understanding of the candidate’s skills and how they might perform in your business.

How to Choose References That Matter

Not all references are created equal. You do not want to waste your time talking to someone who barely knows the candidate or who has only positive things to say because they are a close friend. Here are some tips for getting the most valuable references:

Look for Professional References: These are people who have worked directly with the candidate, like former managers, supervisors, or colleagues. They can give you real insight into how the candidate performed in a work setting.
Focus on Recent Jobs: The more recent the reference, the more relevant it will be to the candidate’s current skill set and work ethic. A reference from 10 years ago might not be as helpful as one from the last job they held.
Ask for Specific Examples: Do not settle for vague praise like “They were great to work with.” Ask for concrete examples of how the candidate handled difficult situations, managed projects, or contributed to the team.

Red Flags to Watch Out For

Just like when buying a used car, there are red flags to look out for when checking references. If you hear any of the following, it might be a good idea to dig deeper:

Hesitation or Vagueness: If the reference seems unsure about answering questions or gives vague responses, that could be a sign that something is off.
Negative Feedback Without Details: If a reference says something negative but cannot provide specific examples, it might just be a personal bias. Dig deeper to find out if it is a legitimate concern.
Inconsistent Information: If the reference gives details that do not match what the candidate has told you, that could be a sign that the candidate is not being entirely truthful.

How Many References Should You Check?

There is no magic number when it comes to checking references, but most employers aim for 2 to 3 solid references. It is like getting a second, third, and even fourth opinion before making an important decision. The more reliable sources you have, the better you can assess whether the candidate is right for your business.

What If a Candidate Cannot Provide References?

This can be tricky. Maybe the candidate is fresh out of school and does not have a long work history. Or maybe they worked at a company that went out of business. Whatever the reason, not having references should not automatically disqualify a candidate.

In this case, ask for alternative references, like a mentor, a professor, or even a client if they have done freelance work. You can also ask the candidate to provide examples of their work or take part in a skills assessment as part of the hiring process.

The Legal Side of Employment Reference Checks

Now, before you start dialing up a candidate’s old boss, you need to be aware of the legal landscape surrounding employment reference checks. Different states and countries have various laws that protect both the employer and the employee.

Defamation: A reference cannot give false information that could harm the candidate’s reputation. If a reference lies about the candidate and it impacts their ability to get the job, the candidate could potentially sue.
Consent: You must have the candidate’s permission to contact their references. This is not just about good manners; it is often required by law.

Final Thoughts: Making the Right Decision

Hiring is like choosing a new family member. You want someone who fits in well, adds value, and sticks around for the long haul. Employment reference checks are one of the best ways to make sure you are making the right choice.

Do not skip this step. It may seem like an extra task in an already busy hiring process, but it can save you a lot of headaches down the line. After all, you would not buy a car without checking under the hood, would you?

By understanding how employment reference checks work and why they matter, you can make smarter, more informed hiring decisions that benefit your business in the long run. Remember, a little legwork now can save you a world of trouble later.

‍