8 min read

What You Need to Know About Character Reference Checks

This comprehensive guide explains the critical importance of character reference checks in the hiring process, revealing how they provide deeper insights into a candidate's personal traits, integrity, and behavior beyond their professional resume. For anyone involved in hiring, this article offers invaluable guidance on conducting effective character reference checks that can help build a more trustworthy and cohesive team - I highly recommend reading the full piece to fully understand how to make more informed hiring decisions.

So, you are getting ready to bring someone new on board, and everything looks great on paper—fantastic resume, glowing skills, and the perfect fit for the job. But how do you really know who they are as a person? That is where character reference checks come in. Sure, you can read all the qualifications in the world, but do they tell you about how someone handles tough situations or treats their colleagues?

Hiring is like building a puzzle. You might have all the right pieces, but until you get that character piece, the picture is incomplete. In this guide, we are going to walk you through what a character reference check really is, how it works, and why it is so valuable for your business.

‍

What Are Character Reference Checks?

Let us cut to the chase: Character reference checks are a way to dig a little deeper into who a person is, beyond the job title and qualifications. You are asking someone who knows the candidate personally (usually outside of work) to share insights about their personal character and individual traits.

Think of it like getting a second opinion. You want to know, “Does this person keep their word? How do they handle challenges? Do they get along with others?” A character reference gives you answers to these kinds of questions, which you might not get from a job reference alone.

Unlike professional references that focus on job performance, character references provide a peek into the person’s values, temperament, and personality. It is not just about how they work; it is about who they are when no one is watching.

‍

Why You Should Care About Character Reference Checks

You might be wondering, "Why should I bother with character reference checks when I have already gone through the resume, the interview, and the professional references?" Well, it is simple—people are more than their work history. You can teach someone how to do a job, but you cannot teach someone to have integrity, be dependable, or be respectful of others.

Here is where these checks become invaluable. Let us say you are hiring for a customer-facing role. Sure, the candidate may know how to process orders, but are they patient and kind when customers get a little... well, testy? A character reference check can give you that kind of insight, helping you make a more informed decision. After all, hiring someone is a bit like getting into a relationship. You want to know who they are when things get tough, not just when everything is sunshine and roses.

‍

What Makes a Good Character Reference?

Not just anyone can be a good character reference. You do not want someone who just knows the candidate in passing or someone who is going to paint a perfect picture without any real substance. You are looking for someone who has spent enough time with the candidate to understand their individual traits and personal character in a variety of settings.

Here are a few guidelines for finding a good character reference:

Personal but Objective: The reference should know the candidate personally but be able to give you an honest assessment. A best friend might be a little too close to the situation, but a community member or mentor can often strike the right balance.
Long-Term Relationship: Ideally, the reference should have known the candidate for more than just a few months. Longer relationships allow the reference to speak about the candidate’s consistency over time.
Multiple Perspectives: You want someone who has seen the candidate in different lights—maybe how they handle both successes and challenges. This provides a more well-rounded view of the person’s character.

‍

What Should You Ask in a Character Reference Check?

Alright, you have got your reference lined up, now what? Time to ask the right questions! Here is where the magic happens. You want to go beyond “Are they nice?” or “Would you recommend them?” Dig deeper. Ask questions that get to the heart of the person.

Here are some examples:

How does the candidate handle stress or conflict?
- Everyone has bad days. How do they deal with them? Do they stay calm, or do they snap under pressure?
How does the candidate treat others, especially people who cannot do anything for them?
- This one is key. It shows you their true nature. Do they treat everyone with respect, or only those in higher positions?
Can you describe a time when the candidate had to show leadership or responsibility outside of work?
- This question helps reveal how the candidate handles personal responsibilities. Are they the person people look to for guidance, even when it is not a job requirement?
How would you describe the candidate’s level of integrity?
- Integrity is one of those things you cannot fake. Ask for real examples of when they had to make a tough decision and how they handled it.
What is the candidate like in a team setting?
- Whether you are hiring for a small business or a larger company, teamwork is essential. How well does this person fit into a group dynamic?

‍

Common Myths About Character Reference Checks

Now, let us clear up a few common myths about character reference checks. There are a lot of misconceptions that make employers hesitant to include them in their hiring process. Let us put those to rest.

Myth 1: Character reference checks are not reliable.
In reality, they are one of the best ways to get to know a candidate beyond the resume. While professional references focus on tasks, character references focus on the person behind the tasks.
Myth 2: They are a waste of time.
Some may think this step is unnecessary, but it can save you from making a bad hire. It is like an insurance policy—better to spend a little time upfront than deal with costly mistakes down the line.
Myth 3: Only friends and family provide character references.
Actually, anyone who knows the candidate personally and has spent time with them in meaningful situations can give a good character reference. It could be a coach, a neighbor, or someone from a community group.

‍

The Impact of Character Reference Checks on Your Business

So, what is the bottom line for your business? Character reference checks are not just another hoop to jump through—they are a way to protect your company from potential headaches. Imagine hiring someone who seems great on paper but turns out to be unreliable or difficult to work with. That could lead to a toxic work environment, decreased morale, and higher turnover.

On the other hand, when you take the time to gather insights about someone’s personal character and individual traits, you are more likely to build a team that gels well together, respects one another, and works toward common goals.

In short, these checks help you avoid costly hiring mistakes by giving you the information that you cannot get from a resume or a quick interview. And, when your team is made up of trustworthy, reliable people, it is a lot easier to focus on growing your business instead of putting out fires.

‍

Conclusion: Get the Full Picture Before Making a Decision

When you are about to make a hiring decision, do not just focus on the skills and qualifications. Get the full picture with character reference checks. They give you insight into who the person really is and how they are likely to behave in your work environment. After all, a great hire is not just about what someone does; it is about who they are.

So, before you hand over that job offer, take the extra step to make sure you are getting a team member you can trust. Because when it comes to hiring, character counts just as much as skills.

‍

Feel free to reach out to us if you need help setting up or conducting character reference checks for your next hire. We are here to make the process as smooth and thorough as possible!

‍